Australian judges protest Israel’s judicial overhaul

The Australian Judicial Officers Association has put out a statement criticising the Israeli government’s plans to reduce judicial independence.

The Australian Judicial Officers Association (AJOA), which comprises more than 700 Australian judges and magistrates, has released a statement expressing its concern about the proposed reforms to Israel’s legal system.

The statement criticises “the curtailment of the capacity of that nation’s highest court, the Supreme Court”, in a bill before the Knesset.

“The proposed laws would, if passed, severely restrict the power of the Supreme Court to review statutes made by the Knesset, by the application of the Basic Laws or on the basis of extreme unreasonableness and permit the Knesset to override the Court’s decisions,” the judges wrote.

“In their present form, the proposed laws risk undermining the rule of law and jeopardising the independence of the judiciary as well as potentially impacting upon human rights.

“Each democracy will have its own culture. It is nonetheless important to observe that the Supreme Court of Israel is the only check or balance upon the otherwise unqualified power of the Knesset.

“A strong and independent judiciary is indispensable to the rule of law and the continuation of a democratic society. The overriding of judgments of the Supreme Court in particular matters acutely raises the prospect of the undermining of the democracy.

“The Israeli Nation is founded upon the 1948 Declaration of Independence which refers to the ‘ingathering of exiles’ and to the development of the State ‘for the benefit of all its inhabitants … based on freedom, justice and peace as envisaged by the prophets … ensuring complete equality of social and political rights to all inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex … guarantee freedom of religion … [and] conscience, language, education and culture … faithful to the principles of the United Nations.’

“The processes before the Knesset are presently suspended, and discussion is being undertaken as to the proposed laws. The Knesset is due to resume sitting next week.

“The AJOA urges for a speedy resolution of these issues, consistently with the maintenance of the rule of law and judicial independence. It is also hoped that by that means, the tensions presently existing in the Israeli community may be reduced or eliminated.”

The statement was released by Justice Michael Walton on behalf of the AJOA. The association consists of judges and magistrates drawn from all jurisdictions and levels of the Australian court system and more than half of all Australian judges are members.


What Israel can teach the US about confronting a constitutional crisis (Foreign Policy)
Sometimes you not only need to vote — you also need to vote with your feet.

Former Israeli President Rivlin on Judicial Coup: ‘You Cannot Agree to Half a Democracy’ (Haaretz)
Reuven Rivlin also referred to the conduct of some coalition members, saying that it contradicts “everything we wanted to prove as disciples of Ze’ev Jabotinsky, that there is no contradiction between being a nationalist and a liberal”.

Israel’s anti-government protest organisers weigh widening platform as vigour wanes (Haaretz)
As protest  organisers try to restore a sense of urgency, some leaders and activists are in favour of expanding the platform, while others argue doing so won’t help the movement achieve its goals

Photo: Australian Supreme Court judges in their robes  (AAP/Dean Lewins)